4/30/2006

Energy: if you watched Tim Russert on Meet the Press this AM you learned exactly what the energy problem is: the politicians. The participants were four energy experts and one posturing pol. The pol was Dick Durbin from Illinois, the home of corn and hence the home of the ethanol lobby. This guy was determined not to listen to anybody on the panel and was only interested in taxing, investigating (and any investigation better come up with his predetermined opinion), and posing for Holy Pictures.

The experts pretty well explained: refinery capacity has actually gone up during the period of consolidation; ethanol is a pain in the ass; drilling in the U.S. can't be done; refineries cannot be built due to local opposition; a windfall profits tax is counterproductive (Durban saying "fuck you, we're doing it anyway."); world wide demand is up; tensions in various oil producing countries has everyone supply concerned; there is no evidence of price fixing or collusion (not to Dick Durbin who says there is); Iraq oil has not been forthcoming; mpg standards must be raised but it isn't a magic wand because it takes a couple of years for engines to be designed; and the failure of all concerned to plan properly for the substitution of ethanol for MTBE.

Durbin's drooling was a guarantee that the political class will pay no attention to the facts but will pontificate, oraculate absurdities, continue spending like there was tomorrow, thus making things worse.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

there is no evidence of price fixing or collusion

If there is no price fixing, why does every gas station within a given region of the US always charge EXACTLY the same price?

Inference: at least at the retail level, there is no competition. Hnece there is no free market in the retail sale of gasoline in the US.

I'm anticipating that someone will say that WalMarts or Sam's Club stores that sell gasoline usually price it a few cents under the mainstream gasoline brand names.

My reply is, if there is any real competition, why doesn't one of the mainstream gasoline brands underprice WalMart by a penny or two?

-- david.davenport.1@netzero.com

Howard said...

Here in LA Costco, Sears, and several other membership outlets sell cheaper gasoline BUT they have hours like 8AM to 6PM and they all have store links to handle transactions. Your assertion about gas prices is absurd. Here in LA there is a thirty cent range from station to station no matter where you go.

Anonymous said...

Your assertion about gas prices is absurd.

Lucky you if there is price competition among the gasoline venders of SoCal.

But here in the boondocks of red state USA, all the gas stations and Kwik Saks charge the same.

Btw, did you know that the Citgo chain is owned by Venezuela?

-- david.davenport.1@netzero.com

Anonymous said...

We had windfall profits tax and price controls in the 1970's. We also had oil shortages. Do we really need to repeat this stupidity?

Anonymous said...

We had windfall profits tax and price controls in the 1970's ...

Along with CAFE standards that Deetroit carmakers said were ruining their car business.

And fuel prices started trending down.

We also had oil shortages.

And we still have those, sans windfall profits tax and price controls.

-- david.davenport.1@netzero.com

Anonymous said...

Oil companies are not charities. They are not going to spend billions in exploration and developing more oil fields if they cannot make enough profit to justify the risk. Every single shortage we have had has been a result of stupid government policies. The same crowd that years ago moaned when fuel was cheap that gasoline taxes needed to be raised to discourage driving or encourage more fuel efficient cars are now moaning about about high gas prices. When I see the Democrats encourage more domestic and offshore drilling, remove the impediments to build new refineries, eliminate high duties on ethanol imports, eliminate the requirement for boutique gasoline blends and mandate that all new vehicles sold in the US be flexible fueled then I'll take them seriously. Otherwise they are as per usual full of shit.

Anonymous said...

They are not going to spend billions in exploration and developing more oil fields if they cannot make enough profit to justify the risk.

But we've been without oil price controls for the past 25 years or more, and not much new oil or nat. gas has been discovered. Maybe the invisdible hand of the free free free market isn't working. Maybe there's not much more petroleum left to discover.

... eliminate the requirement for boutique gasoline blends and mandate that all new vehicles sold in the US be flexible fueled

Kind of a contradiction there, no?

-- david.davenport.1@netzero.com